Analysis of the Quality of Logistics Supply Chain Process Using Six Sigma Scale: A Case Study in One of the Teaching Hospitals in Kerman, 2014

Authors

Abstract

Background: In the present competitive era, organizations need to use a suitable model such as supply chain management in order to earn and keep a suitable place in the national arena and gain competitive advantage. The aim of this study was to analyze the quality of logistics supply chain process in a teaching hospital of Kerman.


Methods: This is a qualitative research, in which the phenomenological approach was used. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with the personnel of the Procurement Unit who were selected purposively and a random review of 20 product request forms. Finally, data were analyzed using framework analysis, and the process quality was analyzed using the six sigma scale. 


Results: Errors identified in the supply chain included 9 main themes and 29 subthemes among which, inadequate monitoring of the accuracy of the product request forms, inattention to the point of ordering, purchase regardless of the quality, inappropriate archive, inappropriate selection of supplier, and non-compliance with standard time of purchase and delivery of goods were the main errors identified. The quality of supply chain process according to Six Sigma scale was moderate.


Conclusion: Weakness in the information system of the procurement unit and lack of suitable relationship between this unit and other units of the hospital lead to incidence of errors in the supply chain process that can be significantly reduced through implementing an office automation system and electronic procurement system.

Keywords


1. Ghazanfari M, Riyazy A, Kazemi M. Supply Chain Management. Tadbir. 2002; 117: 20-7. Persian 2. Feiz Abadi J. Introduction to Supply Chain Management. Journal of Tadbir. 2003; 131: 47-54. Persian. 3. Emam SM. Attracting Value customers with using synchronized supply chain. Journal of Logistics Management. 2002; 4(11):41-44. Persian 4. Pouya A. Supply chain management and information technology support. Tadbir. 2005; 15(145):27-32. Persian. 5. Hosseini M, Sheikhi N. Explaining the strategic role of supply chain management operations in firm performance improvement: a study of Iranian food industry. Journal of Strategic Management Studies. 2013; 10:35-60. Persian 6. Farzad Firozi Jahantigh F, Dehghani S. Quality management of medical equipment hospital supply chain based on game theory. Iranian Journal of Supply Chain Management. 2016; 17(50): 68-81. Persian. 7. Saeedi Kia A, Motahari Fard J, Riyazi M. Supply chain management. Journal of Ravesh. 2000; 10(61):38-43. Persian. 8. Hosseini SM, Salarmohammadi A, Pishvaee M. Supply chain strategy and selecting manufacturing system. Journal of Strategic Management Studies. 2010; 1(2):89-112. Persian 9. Cooper MC, Ellram LM. Characteristics of supply chain management and the implications for purchasing and logistics strategy. The International Journal of Logistics Management. 1993;4(2): 13-24. 10. Novac RA, Simco SW. The industrial procurement process: a supply chain perspective. Journal of Business Logistic. 1991; 12(1): 145-68. 11. Griffin DJ. Hospitals: What they are and how they work? Translated by Arab M, Ravangard R, Vali L, Kavosi Z, Ostovar R. 3th ed. Tehran: Jahade-Daneshgahi; 2006. 12. Killen K, Kamauff JW. Managing Purchasing: Making the Supply Team Work. 1th ed. NewYork: McGraw-Hill; 1995. 13. Pourkiani F, Vahdat D, Askari Moghadam R, Nazemi E, Dadashi AR. Rating the effective elements over e- procurement adoption in organization by statistical method and analytical hierarchy process case study: Iranian Islamic republic railways. Roshd -e- Fanavari. 2013; 9(26): 37-46. Persian. 14. Peng Y, Shi J, Farahmand K, Masek C, Woodbridge P. Evaluation of Prosthetics Purchasing Process at VA Hospitals. IIE Annual Conference. Proceedings; 2015 Jan 1; Institute of Industrial Engineers; 2015. p. 2699 15. Porter ME. Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. 1th ed. NewYork: Free Press; 1980. 16. William PJ. Understanding the Dynamics of the Value Chain. Industrial Marketing Management. Business Expert Press; 2013. 17. Bendoly E, Schoenherr T. ERP system and implementation‐process benefits: Implications for B2B e‐procurement. International Journal of Operations & Production Management. 2005; 25(4): 304-19. 18. Pan ZX, Pokharel S. Logistics in hospitals: a case study of some Singapore hospitals. Leadersh Health Serv (Bradf Engl). 2007;20(3):195-207. 19. Nejat SA. Success way with six sigma. Journal of Police Human Development. 2007; 3(9): 27-44. Persian 20. Asadi F. The role of Six Sigma on the quality improvement in health care organizations. J Health Adm. 2008; 10(28): 31-40. Persian. 21. Trusko B, Pexton C, Harrington J, Gupta PK. Improving Healthcare Quality and Cost with Six Sigma. Translated by Merolhasani MH, Fyzabadi V. 1th ed. Kerman: Shasoosa; 2011. 22. Vali B, Karari H, Fazlolahi M. Using the Six Sigma methodology improving the performance evaluation process of Iran Khodro employees. The Third National Conference on Performance Management; 2007 May 15 -16; Tehran: Academic Center of Education Culture and Research-Tehran Branch; 2007. 23. Vali L, Mahdavi S. Six Sigma and position of it in health. Journal of Hospital. 2008; 7(1-2): 5-11. Persian. 24. Howie SR, Hill SE, Peel D, Sanneh M, Njie M, Hill PC, et al. Beyond good intentions: lessons on equipment donation from an African hospital. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2008; 86(1): 52-6. 25. Chapman TL, Gupta A, Mango PD. Group purchasing is not a panacea for US hospitals. The McKinsey Quarterly. 1998; 1:1-160. 26. Kumar A, Ozdamar L, Ning C. Supply chain redesign in the healthcare industry of Singapore. Journal of Supply Chain Management. 2008; 13(2):95-103 27. Haji Heydari N, Eshaghi F. Simultaneous survey of the impact of multiple aspects of electronic procurement on organizational performance of the top 300 companies in Iran. Journal of Information Technology Management. 2014; 5(1):1-18. Persian 28. Loghmani M. Offering the model of affecting factors on E-readiness for implementation, supply and E-shopping in transformer industry in Iran. [dissertation]. Tehran: University of Tehran; 2009. 29. Teo TS, Lina S, Lai KH. Adopters and non-adopters of e-procurement in Singapore: an empirical study. Omegae. 2009; 37(5): 972-87.